Why “Working Out Your Salvation” Might Not Mean What You Think It Means

A few years ago a string of words in Philippians 2 (the passage below) had a deep impact on me.

“Work out your own salvation with fear and trembling, for it is God who works in you, both to will and to work for his good pleasure.” (Philippians 2:12-13).

I had often heard people quote the phrase “work out your salvation.” But I had never heard the words that follow it ever mentioned. And then one day, it hit me like a freight train. The ground clause that “it is God who works in you to will and to work” changed everything as I realized “working out my salvation” didn’t mean what I thought it meant. What I once read as a warning (like those found in the book of Hebrews about falling away) I now understood as encouragement not only to boast in my weakness, but to revel in the might and kindness of God.

Let me explain.

Theologians often make the distinction between INDICATIVES (what God has DONE) and IMPERATIVES (what we must DO). Paul grounds the imperative (“work out your salvation”) firmly in the indicative of God’s sovereign grace (“for God works in you”). When He works WITHIN, we are able to work it OUT. Or, to say it another way, we can only work OUT what God has worked WITHIN. This apostolic logic of Paul’s must be grasped to properly understand the appeal.

Note the word “for” that joins the two propositions together. God’s willing and working is the ground clause (or ‘reason’) for our subsequent willing and working. Yes, we work. Yes, we will. We sweat. We bleed. We cry. We strive. We labor. But our willing and our working is not first or decisive. God’s is. In other words, as followers of Jesus, divine grace is the decisive “first cause” of all our willing and working. He moves, and then we move. He wills, and then we will. He works, and then we work.

Another important component of this commonly misunderstood command is the definition of the word “work” that Paul uses twice in vs. 12-13. The word “works” in the phrase “…God who works in you…” literally means “to exert overwhelming force” or “to act effectively.” Thus, elsewhere Paul could say:

“I worked harder than any of them, though it was not I, but the grace of God that is with me” (1 Corinthians 15:10).

We must trace our willing and working back to God’s willing and working. He wills IN US that we might will as we ought. He works IN US that we might work as we ought. This must be the theological foundation upon which we stand as we labor to work out our salvation.

“Turn [grk: "shub"] us unto Thee O Lord and we shall be turned [grk: shub]…” (Lamentation 5:21)

Why I Don’t Believe in Free Will Part 4: The Will is Always MOVED and Never the MOVER

One of the primary reasons I reject the doctrine of free will is because the human will is never the first cause in any act of sin or righteousness. It is secondary. It is never the mover. It is always, and without exception, the moved. It is subject. It is governed. It is subdued. It is not free. It is not the trigger. It is triggered. It is not the catalyst. It is catalyzed. It is not the initiator. It is acted upon. It does not move without being told how.

Genesis 3 demonstrates what I mean:

So when the woman saw that the tree was good for food, and that it was a delight to the eyes, and that the tree was to be desired to make one wise, she took of its fruit and ate…” (Genesis 3:6)

Notice the progression:

First, she “saw that the tree was good.”

Second, she saw that it was “a delight to the eyes.”

Third, she saw that it “was to be desired.”

Fourth, she “took of its fruit and ate.”

After using her senses to observe the tree, she desired it. Her appetite was aroused. And then, after being moved by her desire and appetite, she “took of its fruit and ate.” This is the way our volition functions. It is moved by our members.

Her will–that is, her decision making power–was subjected to her desires. Her will was not free from those desires. It was enslaved to them. Could she have resisted them? Only if an alternative superior pleasure was offered. The tragedy of the Fall is that the fruit was the superior pleasure (not in actuality but in perception).

Thus, believing the fruit to be “good,” “delightful,” and “desirable,” Eve was “deceived” by Satan (2 Cor. 11:1-3). How did Satan deceive her? But awakening desires. Because when our desires are awakened, our will stands no chance. The only way we can will our way out of temptation is because a stronger desire has been awakened in us towards a superior pleasure than that which is being offered.

Why I Don’t Believe in Free Will Part 3: Desires Determine Our Decisions

As another installment in this series of short posts explaining “Why I Don’t Believe In Free Will” I want to give an example that displays the true nature of our volition.

Let me paint a picture to demonstrate.

Date night. Me. My wife. And a string of trivial decisions to make. I choose the time (7pm) and the place (Italian). We arrive and the waiter asks what we want to drink. I order Coke. Anna orders water. The waiter returns. “Have you decided on a main?” I say “Steak.” He responds asking “How do you want it cooked?” “Medium-rare” I say. He then asks my wife who orders Vegetarian Lasagna.

A string of options presented us with a number of opportunities to exert our volition. We were free to choose whatever we wanted! So of course we must have free wills! Or do we? [Read more...]

Why I Don’t Believe in Free Will Part 2 – Spurgeon, Edwards, & Whitefield

For years I believed in the doctrine of free will. But honestly considering (1) Scripture, (2) Church history, and (3) personal experience forced me to abandon it.

Below are quotes from three of my heroes from Church history that urged me to reconsider what I had so hastily embraced.

Charles Haddon Spurgeon (1834-1892):

“I do not come into this pulpit hoping that perhaps somebody will of his own free will return to Christ. My hope lies in another quarter. I hope that my Master will lay hold of some of them and say, “You are mine, and you shall be mine. I claim you for myself.” My hope arises from the freeness of grace, and not from the freedom of the will.  Free will carried many a soul to hell, but never a soul to heaven.”

“…it has already been proved beyond [Read more...]

Why I Don’t Believe in Free Will Part 1

The doctrine of free-will is as widely accepted in the Church as core doctrines of the faith like the incarnation and resurrection. Having embraced it myself for some time (believing it to be indispensable to true Christianity) I’ve since come to abandon it. This is the first of a series of short posts explaining some of the reasons why.

The Definition of Freedom

Before approaching the Biblical basis of the idea of free will we need a working definition of the terms. Here’s how Encarta defines some key words and phrases related to the subject of volitional freedom:

Ultimate self-determination: the ability or right to make your own decisions without interference from others

Free: not regulated: not controlled, restricted, or regulated by any external thing

Freedom: release from captivity or slavery: release or rescue from being physically bound, or from being confined, enslaved, captured, or imprisoned

So when we say “free will” we mean “the ability to make decisions without interference,” while [Read more...]

Why I Believe God Wills and Works Before We Do

DOWNLOAD THE ARTICLE

Wading Through the Mire of the Free-Will Debate in Our Pursuit of Jesus

DOWNLOAD THE ARTICLE

How the Idea of “Free-Will” Undermines Evangelism and Cripples Evangelists

DOWNLOAD THE ARTICLE

3 Reasons Why Predestination Makes Me Praise God Instead of Protesting Against Him

DOWNLOAD THE ARTICLE

The Bondage and Liberation of the Will – The Horror of the Fall and the Glory of Grace (BOOK)

DOWNLOAD